Jonathan Karl, ABC News anchor, looked into the camera on "This Week" and delivered this line with a straight face: "I think most Democrats would say they're not communists. So, there aren't a lot of communists on the ballot."
House Majority Whip Tom Emmer didn't blink. "Well you're wrong, they are communists."
The exchange has been burning through conservative social media ever since. Emmer, who represents Minnesota's 6th Congressional District, wasn't there to play the polite Republican guest who nods along while the host reframes the question. He came loaded.
"Jon, you just called them what they want you to call them," Emmer told Karl. "There's nothing democratic about socialism." He then laid out the platform in terms Karl clearly wasn't prepared to rebut: "They want to defund the police. They want to defund prisons. They want government-only health care. And they want the Green New Deal, which will cost every American family another $355,000."
Karl's original framing — that calling Democrats communists is some kind of fringe exaggeration — collapses the moment you look at what the party's rising stars actually advocate. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York's 14th District is a card-carrying member of the Democratic Socialists of America. A democratic socialist currently holds the New York City mayor's office. A DSA candidate is running for mayor of Los Angeles. The platform isn't hiding. The label is the only thing in dispute.
Emmer's $355,000 figure for the Green New Deal's per-family cost is the kind of number that ends a cable news segment early. Karl didn't challenge it. He didn't have a number of his own. He had a feeling — that most Democrats would say they're not communists — and Emmer had a fact sheet.
President Trump once told Karl he had "a lot of hate in your heart." Whether that's true is between Karl and his cardiologist. What's visible to anyone who watched this clip is that Karl walked into a policy debate armed with nothing but the Democratic Party's preferred terminology and assumed that would be enough.
This is what happens when you send someone who actually knows the platform onto a Sunday show. Emmer didn't raise his voice. He didn't get personal. He listed what the Democratic Socialists of America actually want, used the word the platform earns, and let the anchor sit there with no rebuttal.
Karl's line — "there aren't a lot of communists on the ballot" — is technically accurate in the same way that saying there aren't a lot of fast-food restaurants on the highway is technically accurate if you refuse to count McDonald's. The DSA candidates are on the ballot. The policies are in the platform. The $355,000 price tag is in the analysis.







