Eighteen states and the District of Columbia have now signed onto the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact — a legal mechanism that would force their electors to vote for whoever wins the national popular vote, regardless of how their own state voted. The compact kicks in the moment its member states control 270 electoral votes. They're not there yet. But five states that just flipped to full Democratic trifectas — Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin — could push them over the line.
The Constitution doesn't need amending, apparently. Just routing around.
The compact has been a pet project of the institutional left for years, but Just The News reports it's gained serious new momentum after the 2026 midterms delivered Democratic trifectas in all five of those swing states. Governor-elect David Crowley in Wisconsin, Governor Josh Shapiro in Pennsylvania, and Governor Mikie Sherrill in New Jersey now sit in precisely the positions needed to ram this through their legislatures with no Republican input required.
Sherrill made the pitch on MSNBC with the kind of line that sounds reasonable until you think about it for four seconds. "Our votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is," she said. "That's not democracy."
New Jersey went for the Democratic presidential candidate by double digits in every recent cycle. Sherrill's voters aren't underrepresented. They're outvoted in the national count by a system designed to prevent California and New York from dictating terms to the other 48 states. The Founders had a word for pure majority rule. They rejected it.
Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 of the Constitution gives state legislatures authority over how electors are appointed — which is the legal hook the compact hangs on. But Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 restricts interstate compacts that increase state power at the expense of others, and requires congressional consent for agreements that affect the balance of political authority. The compact has never received that consent. The Supreme Court in Chiafalo v. Washington upheld state laws controlling how electors vote, but that case dealt with faithless elector penalties — not a multistate pact to override the electoral map entirely.
Attorney General Todd Blanche isn't waiting to find out how courts sort the distinction. "It shouldn't get past the district court," Blanche said on Life, Liberty, and Levin. "I am optimistic that the Supreme Court will never even have to deal with this. We will take it to the Supreme Court if we have to."
The legal challenges are real. A prior case, Miller v. Washington in 2019, was dismissed for lack of standing — nobody had been harmed yet because the compact hadn't taken effect. That changes the moment the 270-vote threshold is crossed and an elector is forced to disregard the will of their own state's voters.
Inez Feltscher Stepman, senior policy and legal analyst at the Independent Women's Forum, has pointed out what the compact's backers prefer not to discuss: the arrangement only survives as long as it benefits Democrats. The moment a Republican wins the popular vote — as Trump did in 2024 — blue states would face the spectacle of handing their electors to the candidate their voters rejected. The incentive to withdraw would be instant and overwhelming.
That's the structural problem nobody on the left wants to game out. Before the 21st century, the popular vote winner lost the Electoral College exactly three times — 1824, 1876, and 1888. It happened twice in sixteen years recently, in 2000 and 2016, and Democrats treated both results as illegitimate. The compact isn't a principle. It's a reaction to George W. Bush and Donald Trump dressed up in constitutional language.
Five state legislatures, five party-line votes, and the system that has selected every American president for 237 years gets bypassed without a single constitutional amendment. No supermajority in Congress. No ratification by three-fourths of the states. Just a workaround.
The 2024 election proved the Electoral College wasn't the problem. Trump won the popular vote and the Electoral College. The system worked exactly as designed — it just didn't produce the right loser.







