Judge Greenlights Trump's $15 Billion Defamation Suit Against the New York Times

0
Judge Greenlights Trump's $15 Billion Defamation Suit Against the New York Times

Fifteen billion dollars. That's the number sitting on the New York Times's legal desk after U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday ruled this week that President Trump's defamation lawsuit against the paper and publisher Penguin Random House can move forward toward trial. The suit centers on the 2024 book "Lucky Loser," co-authored by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, which accused Trump of committing complex tax crimes.

A George H.W. Bush appointee just told two of the Times's star reporters they may have made it all up.

Judge Merryday, based in Tampa, Florida, found that Trump "plausibly alleged" Buettner and Craig lacked adequate support for the statements they published. That's legal language for: you wrote something you couldn't back up, and now you're going to have to prove it in court. The ruling clears the book-related claims for discovery and potential trial — meaning the Times will have to open its files, hand over its notes, and explain exactly how two veteran reporters arrived at accusations of criminal tax fraud against a sitting president.

The judge did dismiss two related claims involving separate newspaper articles — one co-authored by Buettner and Craig, and another by Peter Baker, the Times's Chief White House Correspondent. Those articles apparently met the legal threshold. The book did not.

That distinction matters. The newspaper articles, presumably edited through the Times's standard pipeline, survived the motion to dismiss. The book — a longer, more ambitious project published through Penguin Random House — is the one a federal judge says doesn't hold up. The format that gave Buettner and Craig more room to build their case is the same format where, according to the court, they apparently didn't bother building one.

The Times has spent decades wrapping itself in the First Amendment like it's a bulletproof vest. And in most defamation cases involving public figures, the legal standard — actual malice — makes that vest nearly impenetrable. You have to prove the publisher knew the material was false or acted with reckless disregard for whether it was true. Judge Merryday looked at "Lucky Loser" and said Trump cleared that bar well enough to get to trial.

Consider what discovery looks like for the New York Times. Internal emails between Buettner, Craig, and their editors. Communications with Penguin Random House about fact-checking. Draft manuscripts showing what was changed and what wasn't. Source files. The machinery behind the story — all of it now potentially subject to subpoena.

The paper that built its modern identity on investigating Trump's finances is about to have its own editorial process investigated under oath.

Imagine, for a moment, if Fox News had published a book accusing Barack Obama of complex tax crimes without adequate sourcing. The journalism school panels would still be running. Pulitzer committees would be issuing statements. Media reporters at every outlet in the country would be writing think pieces about the death of editorial standards. The Times would have led the coverage for a month.

When it's the Times itself? The Washington Examiner reported on the ruling. The rest of the media landscape managed to look the other way with remarkable coordination.

$15 billion is a number designed to get attention, and defamation suits against media organizations are notoriously difficult to win. But this case already accomplished something most never do. It survived a motion to dismiss. A federal judge reviewed the claims, reviewed the book, and decided there's enough there to drag the New York Times into a courtroom.

The paper of record now has to defend, under penalty of perjury, the reporting behind "Lucky Loser." Their notes. Their sources. Their editorial judgment. All of it, on the record, in a federal courthouse in Tampa.

That's not a nuisance suit. That's discovery.


Most Popular

Most Popular