Van Hollen Says the Quiet Part Out Loud: Kill the Filibuster, Rule by 51 Votes

0
Van Hollen Says the Quiet Part Out Loud: Kill the Filibuster, Rule by 51 Votes

Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland went on camera this week and said what Republicans have warned about for years. The filibuster, he declared, is "an antiquated, 'antidemocratic,' small D provision" that "is not in our Constitution." His solution: scrap it entirely and let 51 senators run the country.

Democrats now hold 56 Senate seats. Do the math.

Van Hollen didn't stumble into this. He's running to replace Chuck Schumer as Senate Democratic leader, and killing the filibuster is his opening pitch. "I believe we need democracy in the United States Senate," Van Hollen said, "and that means allowing, ultimately, the majority of senators to answer the call of the American people." He clarified in case anyone missed the point: "That means 51 votes."

The timing is worth noting. When President Trump urged Republicans to eliminate the filibuster during his first term, the entire Washington establishment treated it like a constitutional crisis. Trump laid out exactly what would happen: "You terminate it, you'll get Kate's Law, you'll get stuff that you don't even remember. It'll be so beautiful." He also warned that Democrats would do the same thing the moment they had the votes — and use it to lock in election rules that kept them in power permanently. "You'll have voter ID, you'll have proof of citizenship, you'll have everything that you want," Trump said, before adding the kicker: "That will be legitimate, because they can't win without cheating."

Sen. Mike Lee of Utah delivered a speech on the Senate floor back on March 21 pointing out that the GOP had the chance to eliminate the filibuster and didn't. His summary of where things stand now was five words: "Should've done that. Now they're doing it."

Van Hollen's framing is instructive. He's not calling this a power grab. He's calling it "democracy." A system where 51 senators from states representing a fraction of the population can ram through legislation with zero minority input is, in Van Hollen's telling, the will of the people finally being heard. The SAVE America Act — a House GOP measure requiring proof of citizenship to vote — died because of the filibuster. Van Hollen isn't mourning that. He's celebrating the tool that killed it and promising to make the kill permanent.

The argument from the left has always been that the filibuster is a relic that blocks progress. What they never mention is that the filibuster is the only thing that ever forced bipartisan legislation in the first place. Every landmark bill that Democrats love to cite — Civil Rights Act, Voting Rights Act — passed with broad coalitions precisely because the filibuster demanded it. Remove the 60-vote threshold and you don't get better laws. You get laws that survive exactly one election cycle before the other party repeals them with their own 51.

Van Hollen isn't proposing governance. He's proposing a ratchet — one that only turns left. Medicare for All, court packing, federal election mandates, all of it suddenly needs just 51 votes in a chamber where Democrats already have 56. Vice President JD Vance noted as much in a July interview, pointing out that Democrats were openly telegraphing plans to restructure the Senate the moment they had the majority.

Schumer, for his part, hasn't endorsed the filibuster kill — at least not publicly. But Schumer's silence is its own kind of answer. He's not fighting Van Hollen on the merits. He's fighting him on the leadership ballot. The policy itself is apparently settled.

Lifezette reported Van Hollen's remarks as confirmation of what Trump spent years warning about. The headline didn't need much editorializing. Van Hollen provided all the material himself.

Republicans had the chance to eliminate the filibuster when they held the Senate. They chose not to. Van Hollen is now explaining, on camera, that Democrats will not be making the same mistake.


Most Popular

Most Popular